Got the original one from Amazon. It came broken at the welds. Ordered this one from a Michigan (local) site. It arrived quickly and customer service was good to answer questions and emails. The welds are horrible looking, but the rest of the set looks nice. I'm concerned the welds will rust and/or break. Time will tell. The company offered to take it back, but I couldn't find another stainless set that we could use outside (this is for an outdoor fireplace). So we kept it. We've only used it once as it arrived in January. It functioned properly.